Poverty Is About People, Not Money

Many aspects of poverty alleviation work are foggy. How people move in and out of poverty, how they measure successes, and how they raise their children are all aspects of understanding how best to help individuals move farther away from poverty. It is not an exact science, since poverty is about people, not money.

Journalist Andrew Gumble wrote in The Independent (UK, February 27, 2007): “Poverty deepens when the wealthy don’t care. Poverty deepens when the super wealthy simply get greedy. No other explanation is possible.”

In fact, many other explanations are possible.

First, wealth is not a zero-sum game. Wealth refers to real estate, property, and other investments, including how “money-rich” someone is. Wealth is mobile, it flows, it builds on itself, and it can create many things that benefit all of us. Investments by the wealthy in real estate lead to more affordable housing, cheaper goods and services, and many other benefits. The rich getting richer does not come at the expense of others.

The term “greed” is often misused. “Greed” is an intense selfish desire to be rich. Most wealthy individuals realize that others becoming wealthy has little to do directly with their own holdings. And most anti-poverty work is focused directly on helping individuals move up the ranks to become wealthier. Is it greedy for lower-income people to accept raises, buy and sell homes for profit over time, or want to have more wealth? Certainly not.

Second, Gumbel overlooks another vital part of what causes and deepens poverty: lack of opportunity. Low-income individuals face more barriers for getting out of poverty than the rich do. Regulations on employment, restricted access to credit, purchases of full health care packages or else none at all”¦.All these make it harder for the poor to accumulate any wealth. For example, health care mandates require insurance to cover more and more services and medicines. Individuals pay the increased cost for these mandates, with no opportunity to opt-out for less expensive coverage more relevant to their own circumstances. Closing payday lending businesses, intended to protect the poor from entrapment in cycles of debt, eliminates their last possible form of available credit, leaving many struggling to handle unexpected crises.

Third, poverty often occurs when individuals fail to be responsible for themselves. Note that this does not in any way refer to people being lazy. Rather, it refers to the notion that hope for a better future is a powerful motivator, and fear of harder struggles also motivates people to behave differently. When responsibility lies with government rather than with individuals, people gradually come to think that government will take care of them. Many people living in poverty have a strong sense of entitlement, believing that their housing, health care, car, job and any number of other things should be provided by government. This transfer of responsibility from the individual to government leads people to be trapped in poverty.

In conjunction with responsibility comes ownership. When government assumes responsibility for the welfare of others, and that comes to be culturally accepted, individuals lose the most important aspect of wealth creation: ownership. The wealthy generally remain wealthy, and following generations benefit from it, due to property rights over their holdings. But people living in poverty have little ownership. Income transfers from one class to another are directed towards specific purchases as formulated by government. People holding assets are penalized for it in the current U.S. welfare system, further discouraging personal initiative and responsibility. There are few areas for low-income people on welfare to increase ownership over their property and income or to increase their personal wealth.

Poverty has many causes, and there are many more reasons poverty deepens. One of them is not that the wealthy are greedy. Andrew Gumbel takes a divisive and emotional response to the hardships many of us work every day to alleviate for others. We can do better than demonizing the rich and calling for more redistribution of wealth. Instead, we can focus on areas to open up opportunities for wealth creation for those who are poor. Indeed, in many places around the world, effective micro-enterprise initiatives and asset-building activities are already successfully opening those doors.

Bina Patel is a policy analyst at Cascade Policy Institute, Oregon’s free market think tank. She has a master’s degree in Social Protection Financing from the University of Maastricht in the Netherlands and over ten years of experience working on public policy and direct service in the areas of poverty alleviation and asset building, both nationally and overseas.

Post to Twitter Post to Facebook Post to LinkedIn Post to Reddit

Posted by at 06:00 | Posted in Measure 37 | 7 Comments |Email This Post Email This Post |Print This Post Print This Post
  • John Fairplay

    Most of today’s “rich” were yesterday’s “poor” or “lower middle class.”

    It is only in recent decades that we have had a large number of people who have fallen into a poverty cycle that spans generations. For many, the government’s subsistence level (the “safety net”) is just adequate enough to remove their incentive for self improvement. To these folks, self improvement – even though it would lead to a better life – is too difficult in relation to the benefits they would gain. It’s amusing that Democrats – who believe so strongly in the theories of Charles Darwin that it leads them to deny God – work so hard to prevent his theories from operating with human beings.

    No nation can be truly free until people are free to fail.

  • sybella

    Bina thank you so much for saying the things you just did. I have been saying the same thing for years, but never so well. We should see more articles like that.

    Our government has caused poverty, the system has taken away incentive.

    Even if they hadn’t there will always be poor among us, for one reason or another, but if the majority of our citizens didn’t fall into that class, there would be so much more to help the truly disadvantaged.

    Thank you again

  • Working stiff

    Poverty is a lifestyle choice.

    If any person will do the following three basic things, the chance he or she lives in poverty becomes almost insignificant:

    1) finish high school
    2) don’t have kids until married
    3) dont get married until the age of 22

    Data shows that people who do this, the chance they are iving in povety at the age of 25 is less than 7%.

    • sybella

      I haven’t seen that data, but I definitely agree with you. In visiting with a man who dealt with business and employees and from my own experience,

      People who finish high school are more likely to get and stay on a job, where people who do not finish or only go for a GD tend to not stay. The man I was talking with felt it was because those that had the tenacity to stay and finish school had the tenacity to stay on a job, where those that didn’t tended to skip around or spend a lot of time not working.

      That is not to say high school graduates are always the best employees nor that non graduates are not, but it is true more often than not.

      The failure to get a job, finish school, have kids prior to marriage definitely leads to poverty because they just cut their chances of succeeding by a lot, they tied themselves

  • Rupert in Springfield

    >”Poverty deepens when the super wealthy simply get greedy. No other explanation is possible.”

    Lots of other explanations are possible, why they escape this author is testament to his motivation, rather than knowledge.

    If one can see no other reason for the poor than to blame the rich, one has no insight into either, for such a person is interested in class warfare alone not economics.

  • ICE

    Poverty is also about politicians who screw up the people and the money.

  • Pingback: scam()

Stay Tuned...

Stay up to date with the latest political news and commentary from Oregon Catalyst through daily email updates:

Prefer another subscription option? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, become a fan on Facebook, or follow us on Twitter.

Twitter Facebook

No Thanks (close this box)