Can Kate Brown overcome her partisan tendencies?

Dan Lucas_July 2012_BW

by Dan Lucas

Democratic Gov. Kate Brown has recently confirmed that she will be running in next year’s special election for Oregon governor. The special election is for the remaining two years of Democratic Gov. John Kitzhaber’s 4-year term. Kitzhaber resigned in disgrace back in February, amidst numerous state and federal investigations, which triggered his replacement by then Secretary of State Brown. Brown has been serving out the remainder of Kitzhaber’s first term (first two years of his fourth 4-year term) for seven months now.

She has been getting favorable treatment from the Oregon media and she even got complimented on her “verve” by the New York Times. A survey back in June found “more than half of Oregon’s registered voters approve of Gov. Kate Brown’s job performance” so far.

It’s a testament to how blue a state Oregon is. Despite the scandals that led to fellow Democrat Kitzhaber’s resignation, Oregon has moved quickly to embrace the new Democratic replacement and to equally quickly try to forget the Kitzhaber-Hayes scandals.

Against that backdrop, maybe it’s not necessary for Brown to change her partisan behavior. She has been a reliable cog in the well-oiled Democratic political machine that has run Oregon for decades.

Brown’s partisan behavior goes back at least to redistricting in 2001. That’s when the Republican-controlled Oregon House and Senate passed a redistricting plan that was vetoed by then-Gov. Kitzhaber. The Oregonian reported “When the Republicans tried to overturn the veto, Democratic lawmakers hid out at the Warm Springs Indian Reservation, where state troopers had no jurisdiction to bring them back to the Capitol.” Apparently Democrats feel OK breaking rules when it suits them. Kate Brown was the Senate Democratic Leader at the time. The Democratic secretary of state then produced a legislative redistricting map that was petty and “about as partisan as they come” – something Brown lamely defended at the time.

Her partisan behavior was evident again in her mishandling of the 2012 labor commissioner race. Brown moved the month of the race to favor fellow Democrat Brad Avakian – a move that was roundly criticized in newspapers around the state, including Willamette Week, The Oregonian and the Eugene Register-Guard, and a move that was refuted by Oregon Legislative Counsel.

In September 2014 Willamette Week reported Patricia McCaig was “working off the books” on Gov. John Kitzhaber’s re-election campaign. McCaig, the self-named “Princess of Darkness,” had her consulting work on Kitzhaber’s 2010 campaign reported to the Secretary of State. Her 2014 campaign consulting, however, had not been reported as required to the Oregon Secretary of State, which Willamette Week noted was “contrary to state election laws.” Despite that, then Secretary of State Kate Brown’s office found that fellow Democrat Kitzhaber didn’t need to report McCaig’s 2014 work for his campaign. Given all that has transpired with Kitzhaber and McCaig – including with Cover Oregon and the Columbia River Crossing – this partisan decision may still come back to haunt Brown.

More recently there was the revelation that Gov. Brown had consulted with California billionaire, environmental extremist, and major Democratic funder Tom Steyer before deciding to throw in the towel on her failed 2015 transportation package effort.

The thing I think is most troubling, though, is Brown’s handling of the whistleblower. It’s a genuinely scary side to her – like something Nixon would have done. I’m glad the state settled with the whistleblower – maybe they were worried about the discovery process in his threatened lawsuit – but the retribution they put him through, including criminal charges, is despicable. Despite Brown’s claims of wanting more government transparency, her partisan actions in punishing the whistleblower who refused to delete emails from Brown’s fellow Democrat Kitzhaber will have a chilling effect on any potential future whistleblowers. Forget anyone inside state government speaking up on wrongdoings for a long time.

Equally troubling to Oregonians should be how our docile media is letting Brown’s handling of the whistleblower slide. Our docile media that has a history of struggling to hold powerful politicians on both sides of the aisle accountable.

Even though it may not be politically necessary for Gov. Brown to change her partisan behavior, it sure would be nice to have an Oregon governor who fairly represented ALL Oregonians.

To read more from Dan, visit

Post to Twitter Post to Facebook Post to LinkedIn Post to Reddit

Posted by at 05:00 | Posted in 2016 Election, Gov. Kate Brown, Gov. Kitzhaber | 14 Comments |Email This Post Email This Post |Print This Post Print This Post
  • Evan Manvel

    Seriously? The most troubling thing about Governor Brown is her handling of the whistleblower? She was the one who opposed charges. Or don’t you recall?

    “I think it’s fair to say this decision was an extraordinary act made in an extraordinary situation,” Brown said, in comments first reported on “It was something he did based on the lack of trust in the system around him. His intentions were good.”

    “Instead of wasting public resources and time in pursuing criminal charges in this case,” she added, “we need to focus our resources on building trust and accountability in state government.”

    • Hi Evan, from a previous column of mine: “That witch hunt was started just hours after Kate Brown was sworn in as governor back on Feb. 18, 2015. Brown then waited 3-1/2 months before saying it wasn’t in the public’s interest to prosecute the whistleblower. The very next day, prosecutors announced the whistleblower wouldn’t face criminal charges. Why did Brown wait so long?” She could have stopped the retaliation against the whistleblower at any time, but she waited 3.5 months.

  • Ron Swaren

    The answer is “Not too likely.”

    If Salem were an isolated bubble in the political world there would be a possibility. The reality, however, is that it is part of an axis where the biggest node is Multnomah County Dems. Under Deborah Kafoury public works expenditures have grown outlandishly and promise to do so further. I live in the Sellwood neighborhood, have crossed the old Sellwood bridge thousands and thousands of times with no fear. I did recognize it was time for a rebuild, and hope that streetcar lines would connect Milwaukie and Lakeshore via a rehabbed bridge. Some experts also testified that it should be rebuilt; and Bechtel Corp. had proposed a $90 million replacement as well. Nothing doing; they went for the $300 million job.

    Now they are talking about $500 million for Burnside Bridge upgrades, $600 million for other bridge upgrades, and a $250 million + courthouse. Of course the MultCo commissioners with insider Kafoury leading, figure they will pull just the right strings in Salem and get a big chunk of state funding or come up with some new fees and taxes.

    It never ends.

    • guest

      Write on, good very observant fellow.

  • conservatively speaking

    In essence NO, not so long as she remains within adhering range of mentor Bill Bradbury.

  • HBguy

    As long as the Oregon GOP remains stuck in 1964 Barry Goldwater America the Democrats in Oregon will be held unaccountable.

    • Natinve, not naive born

      What a tube of bull picky!

    • Eric Blair

      It’s beyond Goldwater America. I don’t think Goldwater could have envisioned what his party has become.

  • Evan Manvel

    “A survey back in June found more than half of Oregon’s registered voters approve of Gov. Kate Brown’s job performance so far… A testament to how blue Oregon is.”

    In fact, the poll found a plurality of *Republicans* supported her performance as Governor (40-39%, with 21% unsure). It’s a testament that Brown, while being a member of a party, is doing exactly what this column complains she’s not doing.

    • Arele

      It’s a testament more to how clever she is able to spin things to a willing media. It appears even you did not know that the witch hunt style investigation of the whistleblower began under Kate Brown and continued, including bringing criminal charges, until it became unfavorable for her in the eyes of the public. Only then did it stop. She is very aware of how the public perceives her.

  • DavidAppell

    If Dennis Richardson had been elected governor, do you think he would have overcome his “partisan” tendencies?

    Get real.

    • conservativley speaking

      Off course he would and should; alas, nutso his Dem counterparts.

  • Jack Lord God

    When your first impetus is to hammer the guy who brought the previous governors maleficence everyone’s attention, the question is not whether you are partisan, but whether being corrupt to the core is a curable affliction.

  • Yonex Schläger Vergleich

Stay Tuned...

Stay up to date with the latest political news and commentary from Oregon Catalyst through daily email updates:

Prefer another subscription option? Subscribe to our RSS Feed, become a fan on Facebook, or follow us on Twitter.

Twitter Facebook

No Thanks (close this box)